On JRE #2476, from March 31, 2026, Rogan spent a long stretch with environmental health researcher Dr. Shanna Swan on plastics and hormone-disrupting chemicals. Then came the practical question: can you actually buy a filter that removes this stuff?
What Rogan and Swan said about water
| Question | What was said |
|---|---|
| Rogan’s water source | “We have well water” |
| Rogan’s filter | “This crazy filter, this giant machine that filters all the water.” He says it tastes delicious |
| The brand | He didn’t name one, and we won’t guess |
| Swan’s setup | A countertop distiller, run at home every other day |
| Brands from Swan | “I can’t name any brands,” though Swan said good consumer filters exist |
| Rogan on fluoride | He says he avoids it in water and toothpaste. See our fluoride-free toothpaste guide |
Which type of filter does what
A “giant machine” isn’t automatically the right answer. Each type solves a different problem:
| Type | Good for | Weak spot | Rough cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pitcher | Taste and chlorine. Some are certified for lead or PFAS | Small capacity, and it depends heavily on the model | Under $100 |
| Under-sink carbon | Taste, chlorine and certified contaminants at one tap | Doesn’t remove everything, including most fluoride | $100 to $300 |
| Reverse osmosis | A broad range of dissolved contaminants, including fluoride | Wastes some water and strips minerals | $200 to $600 |
| Countertop distiller | Minerals, metals and germs. This is Swan’s choice | Slow, takes upkeep and strips minerals | $100 to $400 |
| Whole-house | Sediment, taste and chlorine at every tap and shower. Closest to Rogan’s description | Usually less thorough for drinking water than RO, and costs more to install | $500 and up |
Costs are ballpark figures, not quotes. A common setup is a whole-house filter for the house and a reverse osmosis unit at the kitchen sink for drinking water.
Filter picker
What’s your situation?
Pick the closest fit. Check any model’s certifications against the NSF listing, not just the product page.
Start under the sink
Your utility already tests its water and publishes a yearly report. Read that first, then buy for what’s actually in it. Reverse osmosis is the broadest option.
Test, then treat
This is Rogan’s situation, and EPA rules don’t cover private wells. The CDC says to test at least once a year. Bacteria and nitrates need specific treatment that a basic carbon filter won’t handle.
No plumbing needed
A countertop filter or pitcher moves with you. If PFAS is your concern, get one certified for PFOA and PFOS reduction.
A countertop distiller
Water boils, and the steam condenses into a separate container. Swan called it “kind of a nuisance,” and the upkeep is real. Look for a glass or stainless collector, since avoiding plastic is the whole point.
Closest to Rogan’s
Good if you want filtered showers and every tap covered. Budget for installation and replacement cartridges, and add RO at the kitchen if contaminants are what worry you.
Affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
How to read the certifications
- NSF/ANSI 42: taste, odor and chlorine, not health contaminants.
- NSF/ANSI 53: health-related contaminants, such as lead. Check which ones the model is certified for.
- NSF/ANSI 58: reverse osmosis systems.
- PFAS: look for a specific claim of PFOA and PFOS reduction. Michigan State University keeps a guide to certified filters.
Do you need to add minerals back?
This came up on the show. Rogan had heard that distilled water leaches minerals from your body, and Swan said that wasn’t believable. They then read out an AI answer saying most people get their minerals from food. That lines up with general nutrition advice, though it’s worth thinking about if your diet is limited or you sweat heavily.
If you want minerals back in for taste, drops are the simple way. Rogan’s objection to “remineralization cartridges” was that it “sounds like plastic.”
Sources
- JRE #2476 with Shanna Swan, transcript, around 45:00 to 51:00
- CDC guidelines for testing well water
- Michigan State University on PFAS household filters
This guide is for general information. For well water problems, talk to your local health department.