This came up on JRE #2476, from March 31, 2026, during a talk about what’s in tap water. Rogan’s view of fluoride was blunt, and it’s where a lot of people will take their cue from. So here’s exactly what he said, what the research shows, and the fluoride-free option with real trials behind it.
What Rogan said about fluoride
| Topic | What he said |
|---|---|
| His toothpaste | “I have fluoride-free toothpaste” |
| His water | “I don’t have fluoride in my water” |
| His teeth | “I don’t have any cavities. I don’t use fluoride” |
| His argument | Water fluoridation is “dumb.” “Brush your teeth” |
| The brand | He didn’t name one |
The IQ claim, checked
On the show, it was said that fluoride is “completely connected to lower IQs.” That’s stronger than the evidence. Here’s the fair version:
| Question | What we know |
|---|---|
| Is there a link at high levels? | The US National Toxicology Program reported moderate confidence in a link between higher fluoride exposure and lower IQ in children, defined as over 1.5 mg per liter of water. |
| What about US water? | The recommended level is 0.7 mg per liter, and the report didn’t settle whether that level affects IQ. |
| Are dentists convinced? | No. The American Dental Association says the report doesn’t justify changing fluoridation, and criticized how it was done. |
| Does this show toothpaste is harmful? | Those studies looked at overall exposure, largely from water. They don’t show that brushing and spitting lowers anyone’s IQ. |
One man’s lack of cavities is also not evidence. Fluoride toothpaste has the longest record of cavity prevention of anything you can buy, and the ADA and most dentists still recommend it.
The fluoride-free option with real trials
If you’re going fluoride-free, the ingredient to look for is hydroxyapatite, a mineral that teeth are largely made of. Most “natural” toothpaste has no proven cavity-fighting ingredient at all, and this one at least has trials:
- Adults, 18 months: no new decay in 89.3% of the hydroxyapatite group and 87.4% of the fluoride group. It was judged not inferior to fluoride.
- Children, 1 year: also not inferior to fluoride toothpaste in preventing cavities.
Toothpaste picker
What are you after?
Rogan didn’t name a brand, so these are by type, not his exact tube. Check the ingredient list and the concentration if it’s given.
Hydroxyapatite
The fluoride-free type with actual trials. Look for hydroxyapatite high on the ingredient list and a brand that states how much it contains.
Drugstore fluoride-free
Cheap and easy to find, but most rely on plain cleaning agents and no proven anti-cavity ingredient. Best if you’re at low risk of cavities and your dentist agrees.
Ask your dentist first
Kids are where the cavity risk is highest and also where swallowing toothpaste is most likely. The trial above is promising, but a child’s dentist should make this call. Use a pea-sized amount at most, whichever you choose.
Filter it
This is a separate decision. Basic carbon filters don’t remove much fluoride, while reverse osmosis and distillation do. Our water filter guide compares them. If you remove it from water, tell your dentist.
Affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Who should think twice before quitting fluoride
- Anyone who’s had recent cavities
- People with dry mouth, including from medication
- People with braces, crowns or receding gums
- Young children, unless their dentist agrees
If you do switch, keep your cleanings on schedule so your dentist can catch a problem early. Whatever’s in the tube, sugar and how often you brush still matter.
Sources
- JRE #2476 with Shanna Swan, transcript, around 50:00
- American Dental Association statement on the NTP report
- Hydroxyapatite trial in adults, Frontiers in Public Health, 2023
- Hydroxyapatite trial in children, Scientific Reports, 2021
This guide is for general information, not dental advice.